Hello! My name is Maria, and I am fascinated by World Expos (and food! and culinary science!). In the following blog report, I will examine some of the ways that the foods and culinary sciences exhibited at the 1893 Chicago World's Fair both reflected and challenged American perspectives on gender and race in the late 19th century. I will also explore how these perspectives have or have not changed today. Let's get started!
The Great Exhibition, hosted in The Crystal Palace, 1851
World’s fairs, international expositions, or World Expos, are large, internationally attended fairs that usually last three to six months. They are hosted every few years by different cities across the world. These fairs exhibit new technologies, scientific innovations, art, architecture, food, and attractions of cultural significance.
World's fairs arose in conjunction with nationalism and the Industrial Revolution. The Industrial Revolution was a major technological and infrastructural shift that began in Britain in the 18th century and has since transformed the economies and cultures of many nations across the world. The Industrial Revolution was characterized by the rise of factories, machine manufacturing, mass production of material goods, and many new innovations in transportation, communication, and more. Nationalism is a modern ideology that asserts that the world is divided into nations, each of which has a unique culture, history, and national identity (Triandafyllidou 1998, 595). To understand the inseparability of nationalism and industrialization to world’s fairs, one need look no further than the title of the first world’s fair, which set the precedent for all that would follow it: the "Great Exhibition of the Works of Industry of All Nations.” Also called the Great Exhibition, this fair was hosted in London in 1851. The fair took place inside of The Crystal Palace, an impressive building constructed out of iron and glass. Although many nations participated in the event, Britain celebrated itself as the leading, superior nation in technological, economic, and cultural development.
Since then, there have been well over a hundred world’s fairs. In 1928, the Bureau International des Expositions (BIE) was established in Paris to oversee and organize official World Expos. To this day, the BIE still manages World Expos, including Expo 2025, which will be held in Osaka, Japan, this coming April. For the purposes of this analysis, I will be focusing primarily on the World’s Columbian Exposition, which was a world’s fair held in Chicago in 1893.
The 1893 Chicago World’s Fair was also called the World’s Columbian Exposition because it was intended to celebrate the 400th anniversary of the arrival of Christopher Columbus in the Americas. As such, although people traveled from across the world as both exhibitors and tourists, the World’s Columbian Exposition strongly foregrounded American innovations, materials, and national pride. The Fair also introduced many new culinary technologies, exhibits, and foods, including the dishwasher (invented by Josephine Cochrane), The Rumford Kitchen (an exhibit by Ellen Swallow Richards), and food products including Aunt Jemima’s pancake mix, Quaker Oats, and Wrigley Company’s fruit chewing gum (Galvan, 2023).
Trademark registration for Aunt Jemima’s Pancake Flour brand Self Raising Flour. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division.
Wm. Wrigley Jr. Company Juicy Fruit gum tin, c. 1893. National Museum of American History.
From page 9 of The Official Guide to the World’s Columbian Exposition, published in 1893.
Bertha Honore Palmer
Leading up to the World's Columbian Exposition, women activists advocated for an official role in the organization and management of the fair. It was through these efforts that the Board of Lady Managers was established by the U.S. Congress. The president of the Board of Lady Managers was Bertha Honore Palmer, a wealthy Chicago businesswoman. Palmer sponsored the construction of the Woman's Building, one of the fourteen major exhibit halls at the Exposition. The building was designed and decorated entirely by female architects and artists.
Although Palmer was an extremely influential and powerful executive who supported education for women, she still held conservative views on the roles of women in society, being apathetic towards women’s suffrage and largely opposed to more radical feminism (Bokser 2018, 9). Also, although several African American women's groups petitioned to join, including the Woman's Columbian Association, Palmer denied African American women from joining the Board of Lady Managers, extending her support exclusively to white women.
In spite of protests from African American activists, including Ida B. Wells and Frederick Douglass, the works of Black, Native American, and Polynesian women were exhibited exclusively in a section of the Woman's Building titled “Woman’s Work in Savagery" (National Park Service, n.d). This segregation and othering of women of color reflected racist beliefs and anthropological theories of the time, including the idea of unilineal cultural evolution, or social evolutionism. Social evolutionism is an anthropological theory that was inspired by Charles Darwin's scientific theory of biological evolution. Strongly promoted by the 19th century theorist Herbert Spencer, social evolutionism proposes that cultures develop linearly from lesser, "savage" cultures to superior, "civilized" cultures, with "barbaric" cultures somewhere in between. Organized to position Western societies as hierarchically superior to non-Western societies, social evolutionism is "moral philosophy masquerading as science" (Engelke 2018, 38). It is false, unscientific, and blatantly racist, though it was unfortunately upheld by many during the time of Columbian Exposition, including the President of the Board of Lady Managers, Palmer.
From page 38 of How to Think Like an Anthropologist, by Matthew Engelke
Several members of the Board of Lady Managers, including Palmer (top center).
The Woman's Building, designed by Sophia Hayden.
Ellen Swallow Richards
Among the many women that Palmer invited to exhibit in the Woman's Building was Ellen Swallow Richards, a chemist, engineer, feminist, and the first woman admitted to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). She is perhaps most famous for her work in sanitary engineering. Her studies on water pollution in Massachusetts drinking water led to the establishment of the first water-quality standards in America. She was also involved in the development of the field of home economics, being a pioneer in nutritional and culinary chemistry (Kaplan 2024).
Palmer hoped that Richards would agree to be in charge of a "scientific cooking" demonstration in the Model Kitchen, a culinary exhibit in the Woman's Building (Lippincott 2003, 142). She invited many other women to participate in the Model Kitchen exhibit as well, including Juliet Corson, who founded one of the first successful culinary schools in New York (Dunlap 2017). Palmer, Corson, and over two hundred other "World's Fair Lady Managers, Wives of Governors And Other Ladies of Position and Influence" also contributed to a World's Fair recipe book titled "The 'Home Queen,'" published in 1893.
Although Richards was interested in exhibiting at the World's Fair, she refused Palmer's invitation to exhibit at the Model Kitchen in the Woman's Building. She did not want to introduce nutritional science to the public as a gendered, feminine subject (Lippincott 2003, 142). She also wanted to have complete control over her exhibit, something that Palmer was resistant to allowing. Richards requested space in the Manufactures and Liberal Arts Building instead, although this ended up with its own challenges due to restrictions on fuel and restaurant permits. So, several months after the fair had already begun, Richards was finally given space to construct a small, separate building, which would become her own exhibit: The Rumford Kitchen.
Colonel Sir Benjamin Thompson, Count Rumford
The Rumford Kitchen
Richards named the Rumford Kitchen after Benjamin Thompson, Count Rumford. Count Rumford (1753-1814) was an inventor and scientist who studied heat and invented many household appliances including kitchen stoves and coffee percolators (Kleppner 1992).
The Rumford Kitchen was an educational exhibit and restaurant. It included an open kitchen, visible to guests, where affordable lunches were prepared. Richards created posters for the walls and pamphlets that were handed out to guests along with their lunches; these posters and pamphlets were extremely detailed and included nutritional information including the calorie, protein, fat, and carbohydrate contents of the available lunches. In her pamphlets, Richards also included a biography of Count Rumford, studies on the positive effects of providing balanced meals to children and students, essays on affordable foods, hygiene, and much more (Richards, 1899).
Above is a page from one of Ellen Richard’s Rumford Kitchen pamphlets, showing nutrition facts for several different available lunches. Below is a FDA (U.S. Food and Drug Administration) nutrition fact label guide.
In the 21st Century, we often take it for granted that commercially sold foods are labeled with their calories and other nutrition facts. But in 1893, this field of science was still relatively new. Many of the visitors of the Rumford Kitchen would have been unfamiliar with the concepts of calorie, protein, fat, and carbohydrate contents in the way that we are today.
Approximately 10,000 people were served lunch at the Rumford Kitchen during the two months that it was open (Lippincott 2003, 157). Through her educational demonstrations and pamphlets, Richards introduced all of these people to nutritional science.
Shown to the left is a FDA (U.S. Food and Drug Administration) nutrition fact label guide. Just like Richard's pamphlet, this label shows calorie, protein, fat, and carbohydrate contents. Today, many people rely on these labels to make healthy dietary and environmental choices. Organizations like the United Nations Climate Change Learning Partnership offer online courses on how to read these labels, such as the lesson included in the "Sustainable Diet" course.
Nutrition science is also utilized in anthropological research today, such as in Daniela Schlettwein-Gsell's dietary nutrition theories that elaborate on Sidney Mintz's core-fringe-legume hypothesis. In many ways, Richards was ahead of her time, educating people on nutrition and health over a hundred years ago.
A depiction of Nancy Green as Aunt Jemima from 1910
Aunt Jemima logo used from 1993 to 2021
Nancy Green's headstone in Oak Woods Cemetary, Chicago
Many food products made their debut at the World's Columbian Exposition, including Aunt Jemima brand self-rising pancake flour. The first woman to ever portray the trademarked character of Aunt Jemima was named Nancy Green. Green was a former slave born in Kentucky. She first played Aunt Jemima at the Chicago World's Fair, under the employ of the then called R.T. Davis Milling Company, cooking pancakes, singing, and telling semi-mythologized stories of her childhood as a slave. Her booth, located in the Agricultural Building at the fair, was shaped like a giant flour-barrel (Manring 1995, 24-25).
Aunt Jemima quickly became extraordinarily popular. She was based on the racist "mammy" caricature: a motherly and submissive African American slave or servant who cooks, cleans, and takes care of her master's white children. This stereotype, heavily romanticized in the South, was combined with Aunt Jemima's fictional history of developing a perfect pancake recipe while living on a plantation. This fiction made her an iconic and beloved character, often described as the first living trademark. Electricity and the new culinary technologies of the Industrial Revolution led to advertising that encouraged women–especially white, middle-class housewives–to cook on their own, without the assistance of servants. In this context, the nostalgic fantasy of Aunt Jemima as a Black mammy servant was appealing to white housewives (Manring 1995). Maurice Manring (1995) wrote that "Aunt Jemima was a pawn in a game white on white, male on female." In other words, she was used in advertising by white men to appeal to white women.
Aunt Jemima became so mythologized that even long after Green had sadly passed away in a car accident in 1923, reporters sometimes still referred to Aunt Jemima as a real person, blending the fictional life of Aunt Jemima with the real life of Nancy Green. For example, a report from Gannett News Service wrote in 1989: "In 1923, Aunt Jemima, 89, and jolly as ever, died in a car accident" (Manring 1995, 27).
In spite of her character's fame, Green was buried in an unmarked grave. She was not given a headstone until 2020, thanks to the efforts of Sherry Williams, the president of The Bronzeville Historical Society, an organization dedicated to the preservation of African American history in Chicago (Roberts).
The character of Aunt Jemima continued to be used in advertising until 2021, appearing on pancake mixes and syrup bottles across American grocery stores. In response to protests against police brutality and systemic racism in the wake of George Floyd's murder in 2020, Aunt Jemima was officially rebranded to the Pearl Milling Company by PepsiCo, with an acknowledgment that she was based on racist archetypes (Diaz, 2021).
Ida B. Wells
Ida B. Wells was an investigative journalist and activist who advocated for the civil rights of African Americans. She investigated and wrote extensively on the murders and lynching of African Americans. In 1893, Wells collaborated with several other social reformers, including abolitionist Frederick Douglass, to write and distribute a pamphlet titled, The Reason Why the Colored American Is Not in the World's Columbian Exposition . The pamphlet was available not only in English, but also French, German, and Spanish, so as to be given out to visiting international tourists. It included extensive data on lynching, drawing attention to the continued violence and discrimination directed towards African Americans even after the abolition of slavery. It also criticized the lack of representation of Black men or women in almost any executive position in the Exposition, in spite of many petitions and proposals by African American societies to participate.
Wells, among others, also encouraged African Americans to boycott the fair, especially on August 25, 1893, which was named "Colored People's Day" (Paddon & Turner 1995, 31). The Exposition officials promised to distribute two thousand watermelons on that day. Wells was strongly opposed to this. The watermelon, although initially used as a symbol of emancipation, had become a symbol used in racist cartoons and advertisements to mock African Americans, depicting lower-class and enslaved African Americans messily eating watermelons (Popular and Pervasive Stereotypes, n.d.). As such, Wells discouraged anyone from participating in "Colored People's Day," arguing that it would only be used to ridicule African Americans. There was debate on this point, however. Others, including Douglass, argued that the day could be used to celebrate and exemplify the dignity and sophistication of African Americans, and that ignoring it would only encourage mockery (Paddon & Turner 1995, 32). Ultimately, although Wells took no part in the day, many African American musicians and performers participated and Douglass gave a well-received speech in which he criticized the fair-planners for excluding and disrespecting African Americans. Wells later acknowledged that this, at least, was a success for the efforts of African American activists (Rudwick and Meier 1965).
Mary Cassat’s mural, Modern Woman, exhibited in the Woman’s Building at the World’s Columbian Exposition in 1893.
Frances Benjamin Johnston's Self Portrait (as New Woman), photograph taken in 1896.
Cover of Ida B. Well's Southern Horrors: Lynch Law in All Its Phases, 1892
The question of how to exhibit and market the scientific and social achievements of women is still very relevant today. On the one hand, organizations and places that are devoted specifically to women, such as the Woman’s Building of Chicago's World Fair, may promote solidarity between women and create environments that encourage and celebrate them in their own right. On the other hand, as was a concern of Ellen Swallow Richards, separating female scientists can reinforce gender biases, such as the idea that culinary science is exclusively feminine. Furthermore, the exclusion of non-white women from equal and respectful representation in the Woman's Building prevented it from being a truly welcoming place for all women. Ethnic minority participants of the Exposition often had to weigh the costs of taking up the opportunity to represent themselves–at the risk of facing discrimination–or not participating at all, at the risk of loosing the chance to advocate for and celebrate themselves. Some minority groups took advantage of the Exposition as an opportunity to represent themselves as authentically as they could to the rest of the world, such as the indigenous Sámi people of Norway, many of whom made livings sharing their culture at the Exposition (Berg 2012), or African American rights activists like Frederick Douglass, who participated in the Exposition as means of criticizing it. And others chose to reject aspects of the fair outright, such as Richards, who refused to participate unless she could have complete control over her scientific exhibit, or Ida B. Wells, who boycotted much of the fair in protest. Food and cooking is one important facet of how people represent or advertise their identities–their gender, ethnicity, nationality, political belief, and so on.
The rapid innovations in culinary science and technology that were being introduced during the Industrial Revolution didn't only change food and cooking, but also the societal expectations of women. Some more conservative women, like Bertha Honore Palmer, saw the "modern woman" as someone who could be well-educated and "freed" by domestic technologies, but who still embodied the traditional virtues and domestic occupations expected of her. Some women, like Ellen Swallow Richards, advocated for sciences to not be gendered at all and for women to be welcomed into laboratories and scientific institutions alongside their male peers. In a similar vein, some women identified with the New Woman movement, feminists that emerged in the late 19th century advocating for women's suffrage and equal worker's rights as men. Some women, like Nancy Green, became the faces of modern culinary advertising. Women like Ida B. Wells stood for the rights of African Americans, protesting and documenting racism and violence. Visions of the modern woman at the World's Fair were as diverse as the women in attendance. And although all of these women lived over a hundred years ago, the ideologies that they upheld and challenged are still present to this day.
The Columbian Exposition took place over a hundred years ago, but is strikingly similar to many modern day events and establishments. Of these, there are too many to name. But for one example, I notice similarities to Singapore hawker centers, as described and analyzed by Andrew Tam (2017). Like the exhibits of the Exposition, hawker food stalls in Singapore simultaneously represent multiculturalism and nationalism; they unite people of different ethnicities while also excluding many immigrant groups; they evoke authenticity and nostalgia while also being influenced by colonialism. In short, they are nuanced; there is tension in their dichotomies. So too can be said of the Columbian Exposition, which, as an endlessly diverse microcosm of 19th century nationalism, industrialism, tourism, feminism, emancipation, immigration, modernity, innovation, food, science, and more, displayed the values and ideologies of its time not as monolithic but as manifold.
As Americans–especially women and ethnic minorities–are now fighting to protect our rights under the rising threat of fascist sentiments, environmental destruction, and a digital coup staged by Donald Trump and Elon Musk, I wonder how we will choose to represent ourselves globally in the future. Expo 2025 will be held in Japan very soon; how will it compare to the Columbian Exposition? What social and political tensions will be represented? What new technologies and companies will debut, and what will their implications be for our future? I am eager to find out; I imagine that it will display great hope through activism, multicultural celebration, and environmental innovation; I imagine that it will also display great anxiety as it reflects social injustices that people still endure today, alongside the pressures of climate change.
References
Berg, Sigrun H. 2012. “The Sami never sold their souls.” partner.sciencenorway. https://partner.sciencenorway.no/archaeology-cultural-history-ethnicity/the-sami-never-sold-their-souls/1463896?fbclid=IwAR1MfPhGoTCjaTx2uE4YZhhGNPl6jGWqG9MTyGWBJApLqOvBZQMZNp4YBAk_aem_AY1deYm0qlbtLAqYFrxY-Sb9OFwskYi2BinPrt6Pojd2PXYoA6GYHJpRvJLxXT8pzdY.
Bokser, Julie A. 2018. “Inventing the Lady Manager: Rhetorically Constructing the “Working-Woman.”” CFSHRC Peitho Journal. https://cfshrc.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/4_Bokser_Inventing-the-Lady-Manager_21.1_Final.pdf.
Diaz, Jaclyn. 2021. “Aunt Jemima No More; Pancake Brand Renamed Pearl Milling Company.” NPR. https://www.npr.org/2021/02/10/966166648/aunt-jemima-no-more-pancake-brand-renamed-pearl-milling-company.
Dunlap, David W. 2017. “Cooking With Juliet Corson, The Times’s First Star Writer.” The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/06/insider/cooking-with-juliet-corson-the-timess-first-star-writer.html.
Engelke, Matthew. 2018. How to Think Like an Anthropologist. N.p.: Princeton University Press.
Flinn, John J. 1893. Official guide to the World's Columbian Exposition in the city of Chicago, State of Illinois, May 1 to October 26, 1893. Chicago: Columbian Guide Company. https://digitalarchives.powerlibrary.org/papd/islandora/object/papd%3A46940#page/1/mode/1up.
Galvan, Jojo. 2023. “Foods of the 1893 World’s Fair.” Chicago History Museum. https://www.chicagohistory.org/foods-of-the-1893-worlds-fair/.
The "home queen" world's fair souvenir cook book : two thousand valuable recipes on cookery and household economy, menus, table etiquette, toilet, etc. / contributed by over two hundred world's fair lady managers, wives of governors and other ladies of pos. 1893. Chicago: The George F. Cram Publishing Company.
Kaplan, Judith. 2024. “Ellen H. Swallow Richards.” Science History Institute. https://www.sciencehistory.org/education/scientific-biographies/ellen-h-swallow-richards/.
Kleppner, Daniel. 1992. “About Benjamin Thompson.” Physics Today. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2809791.
Lippincott, Gail. n.d. ““Something in Motion and Something to Eat Attract the Crowd”: Cooking with Science at the 1893 World's Fair.” Sage Journals. https://doi.org/10.2190/QXUU-WBAF-EWCX-VFMD.
Manring, Maurice M. 1995. “Aunt Jemima Explained: The Old South, the Absent Mistress, and the Slave in a Box.” JSTOR. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26235388?seq=20.
Mintz, Sidney, and Daniela Schlettwein-Gsell. 2001. “Food Patterns in Agrarian Societies: The "Core-Fringe-Legume Hypothesis" A Dialogue.” JSTOR. https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1525/gfc.2001.1.3.40?seq=1.
National Park Service. n.d. “Women’s History at the 1893 World’s Columbian Exposition.” National Park Service. https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/women-s-history-at-the-1893-world-s-columbian-exposition.htm.
Paddon, Anna R., and Sally Turner. 1995. “African Americans and the World's Columbian Exposition.” JSTOR. https://www.jstor.org/stable/40192873.
Richards, Ellen S. 1899. Plain Words about Food: The Rumford Kitchen Leaflets. Boston: Rockwell and Churchill Press.
Roberts, Sam. 2020. “Overlooked No More: Nancy Green, the ‘Real Aunt Jemima.’” The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/17/obituaries/nancy-green-aunt-jemima-overlooked.html.
Rudwick, Elliott M., and August Meier. 1965. “Black Man in the "White City": Negroes and the Columbian Exposition, 1893.” JSTOR. https://www.jstor.org/stable/273699?casa_token=PpAYL0RsQKYAAAAA%3Ag-xxNb7Vyc4BDWGLAmwoYt3xkrojLFD6nnSHIOs93hDbw15s3bAAh0qtnNJO1PVdrvnCvO6IYy-evf2A5J537AwYXWU5es66Lzd3MZ85AN3U7ZL8dvg&seq=8.
Smithsonian's National Museum of African American History & Culture. n.d. “Popular and Pervasive Stereotypes of African Americans.” Smithsonian. https://nmaahc.si.edu/explore/stories/popular-and-pervasive-stereotypes-african-americans#:~:text=Following%20Emancipation%2C%20many%20Southern%20African,into%20a%20symbol%20of%20poverty.
Tam, Andrew. 2017. “Singapore Hawker Centers: Origins, Identity, Authenticity, and Distinction.” JSTOR. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26362418?seq=1.
Triandafyllidou, Anna. 1998. “National identity and the 'other.'” Taylor & Francis Online. https://doi.org/10.1080/014198798329784.
United Nations Climate Change Learning Partnership. n.d. “Sustainable Diet.” UN CC:e-Learn. https://unccelearn.org/course/view.php?id=56&page=overview.
U.S. Food & Drug Administration. 2024. How to Understand and Use the Nutrition Facts Label. N.p.: FDA.
Wells, Ida B., Frederick Douglass, Irvine G. Penn, and Ferdinand L. Barnett. 1893. The Reason Why the Colored American Is Not in the World's Columbian Exposition. Chicago.